Contact Us: (216) 496-4575
FIRST LIBERTY INSURANCE AGENCY
  • Home
  • Quotes
    • Property Quotes >
      • Home Insurance Quote
      • Landlords Insurance Quote
      • Renters Insurance Quote
    • Auto Quotes >
      • ATV Insurance Quote
      • Auto Insurance Quote
      • Boat Insurance Quote
      • Classic Car Insurance Quote
      • Motorcycle Quote
      • RV Insurance Quote
    • Business Quotes >
      • Business Insurance Quote
      • Business Owners Package (BOP) Insurance Quote
    • Life & Financial Quotes >
      • Life Insurance Quote
      • Annuity Quotes
      • Umbrella Insurance Quote
  • Service
    • Make a Payment
    • Proof of Insurance
    • Contact My Carrier
  • Insurance
    • Property >
      • Home Insurance
      • Landlords Insurance
      • Renters Insurance
    • Vehicles >
      • Auto Insurance
      • ATV Insurance
      • Boat Insurance
      • Classic Car Insurance
      • Motorcycle Insurance
      • RV Insurance
    • Business >
      • Business Insurance
      • Business Owners Package (BOP) Insurance
      • Insurance Bonds
    • Life/Financial >
      • Life Insurance
      • Annuities
      • Umbrella Insurance
  • About
    • Staff Directory
    • Client Testimonials
    • Refer a Friend
    • Insurance Carriers
    • Agency Photo Gallery
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Areas Served >
      • Home Insurance for Brecksville, OH
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Quotes
    • Property Quotes >
      • Home Insurance Quote
      • Landlords Insurance Quote
      • Renters Insurance Quote
    • Auto Quotes >
      • ATV Insurance Quote
      • Auto Insurance Quote
      • Boat Insurance Quote
      • Classic Car Insurance Quote
      • Motorcycle Quote
      • RV Insurance Quote
    • Business Quotes >
      • Business Insurance Quote
      • Business Owners Package (BOP) Insurance Quote
    • Life & Financial Quotes >
      • Life Insurance Quote
      • Annuity Quotes
      • Umbrella Insurance Quote
  • Service
    • Make a Payment
    • Proof of Insurance
    • Contact My Carrier
  • Insurance
    • Property >
      • Home Insurance
      • Landlords Insurance
      • Renters Insurance
    • Vehicles >
      • Auto Insurance
      • ATV Insurance
      • Boat Insurance
      • Classic Car Insurance
      • Motorcycle Insurance
      • RV Insurance
    • Business >
      • Business Insurance
      • Business Owners Package (BOP) Insurance
      • Insurance Bonds
    • Life/Financial >
      • Life Insurance
      • Annuities
      • Umbrella Insurance
  • About
    • Staff Directory
    • Client Testimonials
    • Refer a Friend
    • Insurance Carriers
    • Agency Photo Gallery
    • Accessibility Statement
    • Areas Served >
      • Home Insurance for Brecksville, OH
  • Contact

Our Independence Empowers You to Find Insurance That Makes a Difference

Looking for quality insurance that puts you first? Start with First Liberty Insurance Agency!
Get a Quote
Contact Us

Get a Free Insurance Quote

Holding a house icon
Home ​Quote
Car with shield icon
Auto ​Quote
Handshake icon
Business ​Quote
Hands covering a family icon
Life ​Quote

Additional Types of Insurance Quotes:​

  • Landlords Insurance Quote
  • Renters Insurance Quote
  • ATV Insurance Quote
  • RV Insurance Quote
  • BOP Insurance Quote
  • Motorcycle Quote

Call For a Quote:  ​(216) 496-4575

Couple on a trip with their vehicle

About First Liberty Insurance Agency

First Liberty Insurance Agency logo printed home
lEARN mORE aBOUT uS
Importance of independence. Putting you first. In-depth experience. These are what makes First Liberty Insurance Agency different and how we serve your insurance needs on a whole new level.

Since getting our start in 2009, Timothy Rennert has led our independent insurance agency with a focus on providing local and nearby communities with insurance solutions that impact the lives and businesses of those we serve. We are committed to serving your insurance needs by offering a wide variety of coverage options so you can find protection that works for you.

With in-depth experience and knowledge in the insurance industry, we’ve been there and done that when it comes to insurance. We’re ready to put you first by prioritizing your needs and helping you find coverage that brings you protection and peace of mind.

Learn More About Insurance

When it comes to insurance, we've got you covered. Learn more about how our products can help you.
  • View All Products
  • Home Insurance
  • Auto Insurance ​
  • Business Insurance ​
  • ​Life Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • RV Insurance​
Young family

Contact Us Today

    Please enter your first and last name so we can get reply back and assist you as quickly as possible.
    Please enter the best email address for us to contact you.
    Please explain the reason you're reaching out to us and how we can help you.
    Your private information is provided exclusively to our agency and will not be redistributed or sold to anyone else.
Send MESSAGE
Phone: (216) 496-4575​
Fax: (216) 447-0640​
Email: [email protected]

Location:
4200 Rockside Rd
​Suite 202
Independence, OH 44131​

Agency Hours:
Weekdays: 10:00am - 8:00pm
Call Us Now
Directions

We're proud to represent great insurance carriers like:

Encova
Foremost
Geico
Grange
National General
Progressive
Safeco
State Auto Insurance

Navigation

Homepage 
Insurance Quotes
Policy Service

Insurance Products
Contact Us
Agent Login

Connect With Us

Share This Page

Contact Us

First Liberty Insurance Agency
4200 Rockside Rd
​Suite 202
Independence, OH 44131
(216) 496-4575
​Click Here to Email Us

Location

Downtown Cleveland - Cleveland, Ohio Skyline photo by Erik Drost | CC-BY-2.0 | ​6200 Oak Tree Blvd. - Independence, OH photo by Levdr1lp | CC-BY-SA-3.0 | Website by InsuranceSplash